Gel, Liquid, Pencil: The Best Vegan Eyeliners No Matter Your Style

Gel, Liquid, Pencil: The Best Vegan Eyeliners No Matter Your Style

By

Channeling your inner Cleopatra with a dramatic winged eyeliner look? Or perhaps your style is a more subtle line to enhance your eye’s natural shape and beauty.

Whatever your style, a great eyeliner makes creating the look easy. From smooth application to precise definition, choosing the right eyeliner for the look you want to achieve is crucial. A poor choice here and you could end up with smudgy, run makeup and irritated, watery eyes – certainly not the glamour and beauty you were hoping for.

But how to find the right eyeliner for you?

Well, if you are looking for the best vegan eyeliner, you have come to the right place. I have put together a guide to buying vegan eyeliners and a list of the best options available, to help make it easy for you to pick the product that’s right for you.

Things to Consider before Buying Vegan Eyeliners

There are many factors to keep in mind when you purchase vegan eyeliners. The best vegan eyeliner is a very subjective. What may be the best option for you, may not be the best for another person.

While specific considerations need to be made when purchasing vegan eyeliner, and will be discussed at length below, two general purchasing influences are the price of the eyeliner and what people have to say about it.

Price is an important consideration, as the best vegan eyeliner would be the one that fits your budget well. There are some very affordable options, other mid-range ones and, finally, the top of the range luxury picks.

Reviews are a great way to get an idea of a product and its “real life” usage. Lucky for you, we’ve gone ahead and collated all the best picks in one spot, reviewing our choices in detail, so all that’s left for you is to choose the one that best suits your needs.

Style: Liquid, Pencil, Retractable or Gel 

There are many different types of eyeliners on the market. The most popular of these are liquid eyeliners, pencil eyeliners, gel-based eyeliners and finally the retractable variety. The best eyeliner for you will depend on your style and preference.

Liquid and gel eyeliners help you achieve a sharper, colour-intense look, while the pencils and retractables can provide definition, but also help to achieve a softer look with smudging.

While the pencil eyeliners need to be sharpened regularly, retractable liners can twist out to extend the drawing point as the liner becomes blunt from use – or be wound back in to protect the tip from breaking.

Vegan Ingredients

The next important consideration is the ingredients that go into the eyeliner. The best vegan eyeliners are the ones that contain no animal-derived ingredients.

Some no-vegan ingredients commonly found in cosmetics are glycerin, lanolin, and carmine, all of which are derived from animals.

Cruelty-Free 

While it is important to have makeup products made out of vegan ingredients, it is equally important for the products to be cruelty-free.

Cruelty-free products are ones that are not tested on animals – where no animals are harmed in the process of production. No product can be truly ethical if the company has taken part in harming defenseless animals.

The Best Vegan Eyeliners

As was discussed before, there are many different types of eyeliners that you can buy in stores or online. These are primarily divided into four categories – liquid, pencil, gel and eyeliner.

With so many options for each type of liner, it can get a little confusing. To help you through this dilemma, I have compiled a list of the best vegan eyeliners in each of these categories.

Liquid Eyeliners

Barry M Cosmetics Eye Define Longlasting Liquid Eyeliner

Barry M Cosmetics Eye Define

Available Colours: Aqua, Forest, Cocoa, Plum, Ebony and Super Gloss Black
Size: 9 g
Price Guide: £
Buy on Amazon UK

Liquid eyeliners are very popular because of their ease of use and long lasting effect on the eyes. If you favour this style of liner and want an affordable option to use on a regular basis, the Barry M Cosmetics Eye Define long-lasting liquid eyeliner is a great pick.

It goes onto the eyes smoothly with the help of the superfine felt tip brush, giving you the intense colour that you want from your eyeliner. It is also very quick to dry so that you don’t have to delay your makeup application because of wet eyeliner!

Inglot Liquid Eyeliner

Inglot Liquid Eyeliner

Available Colours: 19 shades, including silver, gold, greens, blues, browns and blacks
Size: 4 ml
Price Guide: £££
Buy on Amazon UK

If you are looking for a more luxurious liquid eyeliner, the Inglot variant is an interesting option to consider. A high-quality liner, it is intensely pigmented to provide you a deeper and more precise outline.

The ultra-fine applicator is unique in its capability to enable smooth application, and the liner dries quickly after it has been applied.

The best part about this eyeliner is the number of shades that it is available in. While Shade 25 (a deep black) is most popular and practical, you can get your hands on a range of browns, golds, blues and greens – with and without sparkle. 

Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner

Milani Stay Put

Available Colours: Black, Coffee, Safari and Midnight
Size: 2.5 ml
Price Guide: ££
Buy on Amazon UK

The last liquid eyeliner on this list is from Milani. The Stay Put, as the name suggests, has a long lasting – almost 17 hours – staying power. The eyeliner goes on smoothly because of the ultra thin felt tip applicator and dries quickly so that you don’t have to waste time or risk ruining your makeup, which can be a big problem for some liquid eyeliners.

The applicator is easy to control, helping to create the most natural looks or even the perfect cat eye.

The Stay Put from Milani is available in four different colours – ranging from bright to dark colours – with a sweat-resistant formula that doesn’t get affected by humidity.

Pencil Eyeliners

INIKA Certified Organic Eyeliner

INIKA Certified Organic Eyeliner

Available Colours: 9 shades of blacks, browns, greens, purples and White Crystal
Size: 1.2 g
Price Guide: ££
Buy on Amazon UK

While there are plenty of people who like liquid eyeliners, there are equally as many who like the soft look of a pencil eyeliner.

The INIKA organic eyeliner is one of your best options if you want a pencil eyeliner that is smooth and creamy on the eyes and glides on, without irritation. It is gentle on the eyes, without compromising on the overall effect that you are going for.

If the smoky eye is your go-to option for a night out, you can apply this eyeliner to the top of your eyelid or under your waterline for a dramatic look and then smudge it out to soften it.

Beauty Without Cruelty Super Soft Kohl

Beauty Without Cruelty Super Soft Kohl

Available Colours: Carbon Black, Cedar Green, Walnut, Charcoal Grey and Delft Blue.
Size: 1.5 g
Price Guide: £
Buy on Amazon UK

Beauty Without Cruelty is one of the leading companies in the production of vegan and cruelty-free makeup products. Certified vegan and cruelty-free, they are committed to providing natural alternatives to preservative, chemical-laiden cosmetics.

Their eyeliner comes in the form of a long lasting mineral pencil to give you a soft and natural look that is gentle on the eyes and deep in colour. The eyeliner isn’t smudge proof, which means you can build it up and turn it into a fun smoky eye look for a night out in the city.

For a smoother application, we recommend to soften the wax by slightly warming the tip of the pencil prior to applying.

Beauty Without Cruelty’s Super Soft Kohl eyeliner is natural and fragrance-free, so there isn’t any irritation in the eyes. The product is also GMO and gluten-free.

lavera Soft Eyeliner

lavera Soft Eyeliner

Available Colours: Black, Brown, Blue, Grey, Golden Brown and Green
Size: 1.14 g
Price Guide: £
Buy on Amazon UK

The last pencil liner on this list is the lavera Soft Eyeliner. An affordable option for people who don’t want to break their bank to buy makeup, this eyeliner comes with organic jojoba oil extracts to give you a natural, yet dramatic look that can take you from day to night.

As the liner is very smooth and soft on the eyes, the application process is fairly simple and it goes on without any creases or lumps. Light when you first put it on, it can be built up according to your style.

lavera’s Soft Eyeliner is suitable for use on any skin type. It is vegan, organic and free of any genetically modified ingredients. It is also free of any silicon, paraffins or mineral oil, making it very gentle on the skin.

Gel

Gaya Cosmetics Eyeliner Gel

Gaya Cosmetics Eyeliner Gel

Available Colours: Charcoal Black, Deep Blue and Hypnotising Turquoise
Size: 5 g
Price Guide: ££
Buy on Amazon UK

Gel liners are the tool of choice for makeup enthusiasts who like their eyeliners to be precise and long lasting, and the Gaya Cosmetics Eyeliner Gel is no exception.

A smudge-proof eyeliner available in three vibrant colours, it helps you get the perfect eye lines without any crookedness or uneven edges. All you need to do is swipe it across the eyelid once, without the need for adding layer upon layer. The final product is a highly pigmented outline to define and enhance your eyes.

Vegan, cruelty-free and perfectly suited to those with extremely sensitive eyes, Gaya Cosmetics’ gentle and natural formula creates a stunning look without any smudges or irritation.

Pacifica Smolder Eye Lining Gel

Pacifica Smolder Eye Lining Gel

Available Colours: Tahitian Pearl, Anchor and Midnight
Size: 2 g
Price Guide: ££
Buy on Amazon UK

Pacifica is a company that prides itself on its production of 100% vegan and cruelty free makeup and skincare products, creating natural cosmetics with ‘women, animals and the planet in mind’.

Their Smolder Eye Lining Gel is available in three beautiful shades. Anchor has a lovely bronzed brown look, Midnight is a deep navy, and the Tahitian Pearl is a green/grey with gold dust and a pearlised finish.

What we love about this eye lining gel is that it gives you a smooth and long-lasting finish. What’s more, its use isn’t limited to just lining your eyes. It can also be used to create a base as a cream shadow if you look demands a deeper shade.

The colours dry well and do not leave odd creases along the lines of your eyes. The eye lining get does not smear, giving you a well-put-together look.

Illamasqua Precision Gel Liner

Illamasqua Precision Gel Liner

Available Colours: Infinity and Oblique
Size: 5 g
Price Guide: £££
Buy on Amazon UK

Available in two shades – one a deep black and the other dark brown – the Illamasqua Precision Gel Liner is a great option for those of you who want a good quality gel liner for the perfect cat eye.

The product is highly precise, helping you achieve the deepest, darkest eye looks with minimum effort. The application is very smooth and the eyeliner simply glides onto your eyelids for a higher degree of definition, given you have the right vegan makeup brush.

The Illamasqua liner uses a water-resistant formula to enhance your eye makeup’s staying power, so that you don’t need to constantly touch up the eye liner.

Retractable

3INA Makeup The Automatic Eye Pencil

3INA Makeup The Automatic Eye Pencil

Available Colours: 8 shades including black, grey, browns, blue, green and white
Size: 1.1 ml
Price Guide: ££
Buy on Amazon UK

Ready for action, retractable eyeliners are super convenient if you’re the type to always forget or misplace your eyeliner sharpener or often do your makeup on the go. Simply twist out enough to use and twist the rest back in to save for another day and protect the ultra-precise tip .

The Automatic Eye Pencil by 3INA is a high-quality option that is available in a wide range of colours, ranging from blacks and browns to the brighter greens and blues. Highly pigmented, you get a good colour payoff.

Easy to apply, waterproof and long lasting, 3INA’s retractable eyeliner is composed of jojoba oil and synthetic beeswax to glide on, give unrivalled definition and nurture the skin around the eye.

Paraben-free, cruelty-free and vegan, 3INA believe in providing ‘real, honest and responsible beauty for everyone.’

The Verdict

Now that you have gone through the list of the best vegan eyeliners, you probably already have a couple of options in mind.

To make it even easier for you to decide between the 10 options mentioned in the list, here are some popular categories and the most popular eyeliners in each of these.

  • Best High Street Eyeliner: The quality of the Inglot Liquid Eyeliner is unparalleled, and coupled with the large number of colour options that you get, this is a sure winner.
  • Best Affordable Eyeliner: If you are looking for an option that doesn’t burn a huge hole in your pocket, you should consider the Barry M eyeliner for liquids and the Beauty Without Cruelty variant amongst pencils.
  • Best Colour Payoff: The gel eyeliners give superior colour intensity, making the Gaya Cosmetics Vegan Gel Eyeliner my top pick here.

Want More Vegan Makeup Products?

Finding cruelty-free cosmetics that not only help you to look great and feel confident, but also align with your vegan ethics can be a challenge. That’s why we’ve put together a whole series of posts of the best vegan makeup products around.

Check out the others in the series: